Gurdgiev: Predictions for the global economy in 2019
By: Constantin Gurdgiev, PhD
2018 passed into markets history as the year of risks re-coupling. That, plus the year of historical records. Some were good, but fleeting. One is bad, and lasting. As the chart below shows, 2018 is now in records books with the most asset classes registering negative returns for a year: 93 percent, as of the end of December.
The first half of 2018 was marked by the slow death of the Goldilocks markets - the environment of relatively subdued volatility, and persistent inflows of funds into risky assets. The economic environment was supportive of the Wall Street: low wage inflation and unemployment prints, robust headline growth, and gradual monetary policy tightening in the U.S., moderated by the continued monetary easing in Europe, Japan and China - all offered the prospect of the lasting nirvana.
In contrast, the second half, and especially the last quarter of 2018 offered us a glimpse of what awaits investors in 2019 and 2020. The Goldilocks era was sharply bumped off its pedestal to be replaced by the VUCA (volatile, uncertain, complex and ambiguous) dynamics of the markets consumed by the re-coupling of key risks. These risks are here to stay.
The main driver of the VUCA dynamics is the monetary policy shift from QE (quantitive easing) to QT (quantitive tightening). In the second half of 2018, we witnessed the early omens of the major impact yet to come. Global dollar liquidity conditions have started deteriorating. Having averaged at around 6 percent annual growth rate from mid-2011 through 1H 2018, global M2 money supply growth fell below 5 percent in 2H 2018. The signs of this coming were already in place back in 2017, but few paid any attention to it back then. By September 2018, global liquidity supply was shrinking, hitting annual rate of decline of 1.4 percent in November 2018. Dollar strengthened substantially, with trade-weighted green buck ending 2018 at the highest level since 2001.
Change in the direction of the monetary policy across a range of the advanced economies, most importantly the coupling of the U.S. Fed tightening with the forthcoming end of the QE by the ECB, can trigger a range of VUCA loops - the downward pressures during which the markets can enter self-sustaining sell-offs. Based on our past experiences, we know of at least four such coupled factors, all capable of triggering the next systemic crisis.
The first potential trigger is the sovereign-financial loop. Pressures in sovereign bond markets can propagate through bonds holdings by government agencies (fiscal channel), central banks (monetary channel), and banks (banking channel). Following the Global Financial Crisis, U.S., Japanese, European and other banks have dramatically increased their holdings of government debt. Increasingly, these holdings are concentrated in the bonds issued by the governments of the countries of bank domicile. These positions are not set against capital reserves, effectively leaving the banks without any safety cushion against a liquidity shock or a sell-off. Monetary tightening, by increasing interest rates, is putting downward pressure on key government bonds valuations. At the same time, ample supply of U.S. Treasuries (fuelled by rising deficits and declining Fed holdings of bonds) in 2019 is now set to run into the declining demand for Treasuries from key foreign buyers. Both factors are putting at risk banks' valuations of their bond holdings. A sharp sell-off can trigger the demand for banks bailouts - a cost many governments cannot absorb without a dramatic increase in fiscal deficits, which will push further losses onto banks' balances sheets, leading to more bailouts. The sovereign-banks risk loop - the core problem exposed by the euro area crisis of 2010-2014 - has never been resolved, and in 2019-2020, we just might have to pay a high price for failing to do so.
The second factor that can trigger the next crisis is the impact of highly volatile markets on the value of the financial collateral. As in 2006-2007, the problem is further exacerbated by the leverage accumulated in the financial snd economic systems. So far, declines in the values of shares have not triggered margin calls. However, a squeeze in the corporate bond markets, private equity and venture capital, or a sharp deleveraging in the real economy, can easily trigger solvency problems across the corporate sector, leading to a simultaneous decline in equity prices and a surge in bad loans on banks' balance sheets. Combined effect of major corrections in several markets can trigger a sell-off of liquid assets, pushing down capital buffers and feeding into a sovereign-financial VUCA loop outlined earlier. Chart below shows the extent of leverage in the U.S. economy and the associated decline in the effectiveness of debt to sustain economic growth (see the fourth factor below).
The third factor is the increasing degree of complexity in markets strategies designed to control for risk. Investors hedging of risks arising in one asset class can lead to a cascading sell-off in, or rotations into and out of, different assets. This creates both, contagion channels and increased uncertainty in the markets, effectively replacing priceable risk dynamics with less manageable VUCA dynamics. One example of this from the late 2018 is the large scale rotation by investors out of corporate debt into Government debt, that has been adversely impacting not only asset valuations, but also market signals underlying monetary policy. In the presence of VUCA dynamics, these problems are further exacerbated by market herding.
The fourth, and perhaps the most important in the long run, factor is the real economy's reliance on debt, or the real credit cycle (highlighted in the second chart above). Over recent years, dramatic increases in corporate debt, coupled with reduced equity cushions (due to rampant shares buybacks and M&As, fuelled by cheap debt), have increased corporate sector vulnerability to rising interest rates. 2017-2018 changes to tax deductibility of interest in the U.S. are adding some fuel to the fire of monetary policy 'normalization' by the Fed. Recent indicators from the banking sector show sharp fall-offs in domestic non-financial and asset-backed credit outstanding in the U.S. Net interest margin uplift through 2018 has also been dramatic, and provisions for bad loans are rising steadily across the U.S. banking sector. This problem is even more pronounced in Europe, where structural weaknesses in the credit-fuelled economy, and lack of long term productivity growth are now driving sharp fall-off in macroeconomic indicators even before the onset of ECB monetary tightening.
In simple terms, 2019 is likely to be a year of structural breaks and VUCA re-coupling. Advanced economies' weakening real growth conditions are likely to run parallel to the financial markets characterized by rising liquidity risks, increased volatility and uncertainty. Growing complexity of financial strategies deployed to counter these risks will become tightly coupled with the ambiguity of the overall macroeconomic and monetary policies, as the U.S. and the rest of the world diverge on fiscal deficits and monetary tightening. Pursuit of growth by policymakers and chasing of higher returns by investors can easily give way to deleveraging and wealth preservation objectives. Such a shift, while overdue, is likely to be a painful one for all involved.
Dr. Constantin Gurdgiev is Professor of Finance at Middlebury Institute of International Studies at Monterey and continues as adjunct assistant professor of finance at Trinity College, Dublin. He is a co-founder and Chairman of the Irish Mortgage Holders Organisation, and a co-founder and director of iCare (https://www.icarehousing.ie/), and serves as a partner and a board member with a number of international financial services providers. Dr. Gurdgiev was one of FocusEconomics's Top Economic and Finance bloggers of 2017 & 2018 as well as a Top Economics Influencer. Visit his blog True Economics as well as his website MacroView for more from Constantin. You can also follow him on Twitter here.
5-year economic forecasts for more than 130 countries & 30 commodities.
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of FocusEconomics S.L.U. Views, forecasts or estimates are as of the date of the publication and are subject to change without notice. This report may provide addresses of, or contain hyperlinks to, other internet websites. FocusEconomics S.L.U. takes no responsibility for the contents of third party internet websites.
Date: January 16, 2019
TagsInflation Asia Energy Commodities Draghi Forex Gold Economic Crisis Base Metals Commodities Argentina Company News Unemployment rate Eastern Europe Bitcoin Agricultural Commodities Brexit Housing Market Japan CIS Countries IMF Israel Emerging Markets Central America public debt Infographic Russia Spain Commodities Asean Political Risk Economists Canada China economic growth Latin America oil prices Ukraine Asian Financial Crisis Nordic Economies USA GDP precious metals Germany MENA Budget deficit United States Copper Lagarde election Exchange Rate Cryptocurrency Italy Trade Venezuela TPP Turkey Tunisia Iran Resource Curse Consensus Forecast Exports interview Palladium United Kingdom Costa Rica; GDP; Budget Portugal South Africa Healthcare Cannabis G7 Eurozone Vietnam chile scotiabank OPEC Sub-Saharan Africa Africa UK Oil Economic Debt TPS France Nigeria Canadian Economy European Union Brazil Greece Australia India Investment Colombia Base Metals Euro Area Precious Metals Commodities Major Economies Mexico Banking Sector Economic Growth (GDP)
The oil market has been on a rollercoaster ride since the onset of the pandemic, and oil exporters’ fortunes have f… https://t.co/RjgKVhLdwM
3 days ago
Following two global crises in quick succession, public debt-to-GDP ratios in many countries are now at multi-decad… https://t.co/WYmjrbycxF
6 days ago
Base metals posted the weakest increase in prices since April 2020 in June, following China's announcement that it… https://t.co/NW1R30219S
1 week ago
After years of chronic downturn, the Venezuelan economy appears set to shrink at a significantly softer rate this y… https://t.co/3rUhH4VTqO
1 week ago
Unemployment in Central America and the Caribbean soared last year as Covid-19 restrictions bit hard and vital tour… https://t.co/sTX41IBUG1
1 week ago