Consensus or Individual Forecasts?
Let me start with this: if you haven’t read Nate Silver’s The signal and the noise then I suggest you go pick it up right away. For anybody who is interested in the business of forecasting, Silver’s book is a must read. Silver, a baseball analyst-turned political analyst-turned forecaster extraordinaire, gained notoriety when he correctly predicted the 2008 U.S. presidential election almost flawlessly. In his book, he discusses the intricacies of forecasting and the enormous challenges presented when one attempts to anticipate the future, applying rigorous analysis combined with large amounts of rationality and common sense.
Silver goes over the theoretical and practical aspects of forecasting in a wide range of fields, from metereology or earthquake prediction to baseball and – you guessed it – economics. Be warned: economists don’t come out looking very flattered in this book. In spite of increasingly sophisticated models, for all our efforts, economic forecasting has not improved greatly in the past years. In the book, Jan Hatzius, Chief Economist at Goldman Sachs and a very respected professional in the field puts it bluntly – if perhaps a little dramatically: “nobody has a clue”.
The truth of the matter is that, as Hatzius explains and as any economist worth his salt knows, macroeconomic forecasting is very complicated. Anyone claiming differently is either a fool or a liar. Predicting the behaviour of something as complex and enormous as an entire economy is a daunting task for a number of reasons; some are rather evident like the fact that economies are in perpetual change, therefore one cannot always extrapolate behaviours and relationships from past business cycles into the next one. Some are not. For instance, the sheer size of raw economic data available is something that most would consider an advantage, a sort of commodity that would allow us to test models massively in order to reach increasingly accurate results. Instead, the thousands of economic indicators available produce a vast amount of statistical noise, making the establishment of meaningful relations of causation between variables a serious challenge.
So is this to say there is no hope to obtain success when trying to forecast economic variables? Not exactly. Individual forecasts can and will achieve a certain level of success, but they can be improved upon. How? This is when consensus forecasts kick in.
My friends at FocusEconomics have been publishing consensus forecasts reports for over 15 years, so they have a massive database of economic projections that comes in very handy in order to illustrate the point.
The charts above show forecasts for GDP growth for the four largest economies in the Euro area. These forecasts were collected during March 2012 (and published at the start of April, hence the chart notes), exactly one year before the publication of the final 2012 GDP figures for those economies. This period is an arbitrary choice made by me, but a one-year horizon can generally be considered a reasonable timeframe to evaluate the accuracy of an economic forecast.
The blue dots represent the individual forecasts made by banks, financial institutions and research institutes across the world, while the red dot at the right end represents the consensus forecast for each country. The green line marks the final GDP result published one year later: -1.4% GDP growth in Spain, +0.7% in Germany, 0.0% in France and -2.4% in Italy.
These charts allow us to evaluate the effectiveness of the consensus approach quickly and intuitively. Spain and Germany come up as nothing short of a smashing success, with the consensus forecast accurately predicting GDP growth in both countries. The case of Spain is particularly compelling, as not a single panelist correctly predicted the final outcome, yet the consensus forecast was right on the money.
France shows a more typical scenario, where the consensus forecast is beat by some of the panelists but manages to be more accurate than most. Finally, Italy presents us with a case of a deeper-than-expected downturn, where the final GDP result overshoots panelists expectations, including the consensus forecast (arithmetically, it couldn’t be any other way).
Thus, a quick overlook already shows that the consensus forecast approach appears to be more reliable than a large number of individual projections, with a few exceptions in the overall sample. However, it is when we apply a standard statistical procedure to evaluate the accuracy of those forecasts that the results are extraordinarily revealing. Calculating the root mean square error (RMSE) – a frequently used system to calculate prediction errors in statistics – we obtain that the aggregate forecast is a whopping 98% more accurate than the average individual forecast in the case of Germany and 92% more accurate in the case of Spain. These extraordinary results, however, are the product of the consensus forecast predicting GDP growth with pinpoint accuracy in both those countries, a result that unfortunately is not all that frequent, therefore it was to be expected that calculations would yield an enormous difference against the individual forecasts.
For France, the consensus forecast is 52% more accurate than the average individual one, still an excellent result. However, it is the Italian case that provides possibly the most revealing result of all. As we saw before, Italy suffered a much larger contraction in GDP than anticipated by the market, therefore the consensus forecast fell quite far from the actual outcome and was actually beat by more than half of the panelists. You could therefore think that individual forecasts beat the aggregate one in this case. You would be wrong. When applying RMSE, the consensus forecast still was 7% more accurate than the average individual one. And this proves the central point of this thesis: the consensus forecast will not correctly predict the final outcome each time; the consensus forecast will not beat all individual panelists each time – in fact a certain number of individual forecasts will beat the aggregate one most of the time – BUT the consensus forecast will be more accurate than the average individual projection. Perhaps the consensus forecast won’t be able to predict the next global crisis, but the point is, it will still be able to give you a better projection than your average individual forecast.
Admittedly, my sample is limited to only four countries, one economic variable and one time frame, so those specific error levels cannot be extrapolated to a wide scale (for what it’s worth, I later run the same test for 2012 GDP projections in another 10 Euro area countries and found the consensus forecast to be on average 29% more accurate than the individual ones). Still, it’s a small sample for projections limited to one year, but whether these specific error numbers are significant enough or not, the key issue is that empirical studies show that the phenomenon of aggregate forecasts beating individual ones appears to happen in nearly every field under study.
As I mentioned before, a certain number of individual forecasts will likely beat the consensus any given time, so one may be tempted to try to choose one among those instead in order to find guidance for future results. The problem with this approach is that it has been widely documented that the past accuracy of a forecaster bears almost no weight regarding its future performance. In other words, if you decide to trust someone else’s view based on getting it right once, you’ll do so at your own risk.
Facing an uncertain, unknown future, the best you can do is try to minimize the risk and reduce the margin for error, and that’s where the consensus forecast is a reliable tool. Some of the differences between forecasts and the actual outcome that we saw before may seem trivial to the untrained eye, but, for instance, in a one trillion euro economy like Spain, a 1% error in predicting GDP growth translates into a sizable 10 billon euro difference. Whether you are a policy maker planning the government’s budget or a financial officer attempting to anticipate future demand for a product, wouldn’t you rather be on the right end of that projection?
Ángel Talavera is an economist based in London who specializes in macroeconomic analysis and country risk. Any views or opinions in this entry are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of the company.
5-year economic forecasts on 30+ economic indicators for 127 countries & 33 commodities.
Date: July 16, 2014
TagsInflation MENA Russia Oil Spain Forex G7 Unemployment rate Investment TPP Argentina China Eastern Europe United States India Major Economies Housing Market Nordic Economies Germany Japan Gold Healthcare Energy Commodities United Kingdom Euro Area Canada Colombia France Latin America South Africa Emerging Markets Economic Growth (GDP) Turkey Tunisia Bitcoin Cryptocurrency Iran Asia Consensus Forecast oil prices Vietnam IMF Venezuela Africa Exchange Rate Sub-Saharan Africa Base Metals Commodities Banking Sector Brexit USA Australia Agricultural Commodities Commodities Eurozone Greece UK European Union Italy Portugal Ukraine OPEC Mexico precious metals Company News Infographic Brazil Trade Precious Metals Commodities
Analysts see base metal prices rising 7.6% year-on-year in Q4 2019 (last month: +6.2% yoy). Read more: https://t.co/KlgaC9IbxP
12 hours ago
The Guatemalan economy is projected to expand 3.1% in 2019 and 3.0% in 2020. Read more: https://t.co/JdM2ep1Com
14 hours ago
Argentina's inflation is expected to be 29.0% at the end of 2019, which is up 1.2 percentage points from last month… https://t.co/6Z6z1lcdgY
16 hours ago
GDP in Brazil is seen growing 2.4% in 2019, which is up 0.1 percentage points from last month's forecast, and expan… https://t.co/hHt506suN2
16 hours ago
Agricultural prices are expected to increase 5.6% year-on-year in Q4 2019 on solid food demand thanks to the world'… https://t.co/rBF0qJ4clw
18 hours ago
- Canada in 2019: Interview with a Top Economic Forecaster
- Pound Sterling 2019 Exchange Rate: Projections from Leading Analysts
- Expectations for Latin America’s Economy in 2019
- Ethiopia and Rwanda: From Destruction to Development
- Key commodities trends to look out for in 2019
- What drove Gulf neighbors to bail out Bahrain?
- The Four Financial Bubbles and Their Impact on the U.S. Economy
- The Poorest Countries in the World
- Italy: The sick man of Europe
- What does Bolsonaro's presidential win mean for Brazil's economic outlook?
- The World's Top 10 Largest Economies
- In Latin America, taxpayers are tapped to shoulder the burden of a bank bailout
- How and when will the next financial crisis happen? - 26 experts weigh in
- China and Africa: A partnership under the spotlight
- The conditions are ripe for a Global Financial Crisis 2.0
- Uncertainty, instability and fear haunt a generation of Argentinians
- 5 things: What to expect for Mexico's economy in 2019
- 5 things: Brazil's economic downturn and what to expect going forward
- Emerging Market Currency Crisis: Everything you need to know
- Which ASEAN countries are most exposed in the event of a U.S.-China trade war?
- 75 Top Economics Influencers to Follow
- Emerging Markets Economic Outlook 2018 and 2019
- The Faces Behind Latin America’s Key Institutions
- 2019 Economic Outlook for the Top Oil Producing Countries
- Is your cup of coffee about to get more expensive going in to 2019?
- The Economic Implications of an Aging Global Population
- Can the Wisdom of the Crowds predict the results of the 2018 World Cup?
- Railway Mania: The Largest Speculative Bubble You’ve Never Heard Of
- From Riches to Rags: Have Cryptocurrencies Crashed for Good?
- Investment looks to Latin America, but forecasts are not encouraging
- Turkey: Erdogan has cemented his grip on power - now what about the economy?
- How can Latin America’s business environment benefit from technological change?
- Mexico: A look at the past, present and future as elections yield AMLO victory
- Italy’s New Populist Government and the Eurozone: Prelude to a Crisis?
- Latin America moves toward increased integration as U.S. protectionism grows
- How can Latin America increase productivity without affecting the quality of employment?
- How will Saudi Arabia's economy benefit from lifting the women's driving ban?
- Which countries are the most prepared for the upcoming digital revolution?
- India Under Pressure from the U.S. on Trade Policy
- The Story of Steel
- Latin America is the World Leader in eCommerce Growth Despite Serious Challenges
- What the TPP means for trade in Latin America
- Elections in Russia: Analysis and Implications
- Nearly a Third of Latin Americans Have No Right to a Pension
- A Look at Healthcare Models Around the World
- Newly-elected Chilean President Sebastian Piñera faces a myriad of challenges - economic and otherwise
- The Economic Effects of Trade Protectionism
- Regional Disparity: The Dark Side of Inequality in Latin America
- Coal: The story of the world's most abundant fossil fuel
- Gold: The Most Precious of Metals (Part 3)
- Venezuela's Electoral Conundrum
- Trump's 1st Year: 95 Analysts Surveyed on U.S. Economy
- The Latest on China and What's in Store for 2018
- An in-depth look at the Eurozone’s booming economy and the challenges that lurk in the shadows
- Increasing poverty in Latin America takes a breather thanks to improving economic dynamics
- What will be the most miserable economies in 2018?
- Is Spain doing enough to address its high youth unemployment rate?
- Has Latin America gone far enough in reducing barriers to international trade?
- Commodities Outlook: Oil, Natural Gas, Coal, Lead & Tin
- 21 experts tell us what the future looks like for cryptocurrencies and blockchain
- Turkish lira plummets to all-time low on Erdogan’s monetary feud and tense U.S.-Turkey relations
- Copper: The first metal mastered by man
- Nigerian Economy Still Treading Water Thanks to Oil Sector
- The Mercosur-EU Free Trade Agreement: Obstacles & Opportunities
- Elections in Chile: What the results could mean for the economy
- QE’s Untold Story: A Chart That Fed Correspondents Need To Investigate
- Holland’s fragile one-seat majority government targets economic growth at the expense of fiscal sustainability
- South Africa: Economy at a tipping point?
- Latin American Commodities: What’s behind the increase in demand and prices?
- Is the UK really "shackled to a corpse"?
- Spain-Catalonia: 7 economic experts weigh in on how the situation will affect the outlook
- How well is Spain's labor market doing since the crisis?
- Which countries will have the highest and lowest inflation in 2017?
- How vulnerable is Latin America to economic crises today?
- Iron ore facts and common questions answered
- The bulging economic costs of obesity
- How much investment is needed to salvage Latin America’s crumbling infrastructure?
- A Look at the Potential Impact of Brexit on the Dutch Economy
- Emerging Markets Are Kicking Into Higher Gear In 2017
- Why is foreign direct investment in Latin America falling again?
- Are Central Banks Nationalising the Economy?
- Bounty or burden? The impact of refugees on European economies is far from clear
- What’s the future of U.S.-Latin America trade relations?
- Taxes or cutbacks? Latin America's challenge of sustaining spending without causing debt to skyrocket
- Are uranium prices making a comeback?
- Taxing the Economy: Achieving a Delicate Balance
- How will Latin America’s upcoming lengthy election cycle affect the reform agenda and credit ratings?
- How will emerging market economies perform in 2017?
- Chilean Economy in Focus: Interview with Senior Economist of the Chamber of Commerce of Santiago
- CEOs Rank Top Economies for Growth Opportunities
- The Mobile Ecosystem & Latin America's Economy
- Prospects and Challenges for the Global Economy: Interview with Tim Cooper from BMI Research
- How will the Fed reduce its balance sheet & and how will the ECB end QE? - 19 economic experts weigh in
- Thoughts on "unwinding" QE from Frances Coppola
- The Fed and ECB at a crossroads: Unwinding QE
- Spain: The economy that continues to silence the critics
- Latin America: The Most Unequal Region in the World
- The History of OPEC: Has it been a Success?
- FocusEconomics Announces 2017 Analyst Forecast Awards Winners
- Latin America’s rising unemployment bucks nearly decade long trend
- Escape from the Central Bank Trap by Daniel Lacalle
- China's economic rebalancing act: What to look out for in 2017
- Driving Growth in Latin America: Challenges & Priorities
- Is the Global Economy Rebalancing?
- Commodity exporters face challenging times
- Recent Global Events Facilitate Mercosur-Pacific Alliance
- 23 economic experts weigh in: Why is productivity growth so low?
- Mexico's outlook as Trump nears 100-day mark
- Interview with Oxford Economics Senior Economist on implications of the possible outcomes of the French Presidential Election
- The anxiety of the small saver in a world of negative interest rates
- Brexit negotiations. Between Uncertainty and Urgency
- An Economic History of the EU from El Blog Salmón
- Baby Boomin': Implications of high population growth in Latin America
- Survey of International Economists Predicts a Le Pen Defeat in French Elections, Says Macron has Best Economic Plan
- Spain in a global context: developed economy with some challenges
- How much is crime costing Latin America?
- Predictions & Estimates from Economist Daniel Lacalle
- What economy will the new Dutch government inherit?
- “The data is not a true reflection of reality in India” Interview with Société Générale India Economist
- What are the prospects for Emerging Economies in 2017?
- What to expect in Asia for 2017
- Top Economics & Finance Blogs of 2017
- Latam to Resume Moderate Growth in 2017 but Important Risks Plague Outlook
- 4 Key European Elections That Will Impact the Economy in 2017
- How are security concerns and political chaos affecting Turkey’s economy?
- Global growth to edge up in 2017
- Set to breach targets again? Debt and deficit outlooks for Southern European Eurozone countries in 2016 & 2017
- What does Donald Trump mean for the U.S. economy?
- How will emerging markets perform in 2017?
- The economic impact of a break in U.S.-Philippines ties
- Trump election: Base metals surge due to infrastructure plan
- 5 updates on the Venezuelan economic crisis
- Canada: When your neighbor’s house is on fire…
- Short-term pain before long-term gain? A look at French labor reform and economic growth
- Asia: Unremarkable growth & unfulfilled promises?
- How India's latest monsoon is affecting the economy
- Innovation in Latin America: Potential Goes Untapped Due to Weak Economic Conditions
- Russian economy update in wake of OPEC deal announcement
- The Wisdom of the Crowds and the Consensus Forecast
- Can the peso predict the U.S. election results?
- There's no end in sight to the Venezuela crisis
- A Look at the European Union Political Calendar
- Survey of international economists shows uncertainty surrounding elections damaging U.S. growth prospects
- FocusEconomics partners with leading online statistics provider Statista
- China: Recent postive economic data may be papering over the cracks
- Sub-Saharan Africa's 2016 & 2017 growth rates
- The Italian Dilemma: Weak banks pose risk to already faltering domestic demand
- How much money do migrants from Latin America send home?
- The U.S.' (Not So) Mysterious Case of the Missing Men
- What to expect from the G20 economies by 2020
- The Pain in Spain: Robust GDP growth cannot mask the persistent structural deficit