Italy's New Populist Government and the Eurozone: Prelude to a Crisis?
On June 1st a new populist coalition government entered office in Italy. The coalition of the 5 Star Movement (M5S) and the League represents a strong rejection of previous fiscal austerity programmes, and a more sceptical attitude to the EU and its institutions, with the League’s leader Matteo Salvini having previously stated that entering the Euro was a mistake for Italy. While the new government has omitted any mentions of a Eurozone exit (Italexit) from its economic programme, its policy plans have significantly raised uncertainty in Italian financial markets. Under certain circumstances, they could lead to a debt crisis, which could cause an Italexit. While non-Italian banks have reduced their exposure to Italian debt since the Eurozone Crisis of 2011-2014, some spill-over risks to the rest of the Eurozone remain.
Background: Italian Economic Stagnation and a Political Class without Any Clear Solutions
The new government formed after lengthy negotiations, following the March 4th legislative elections in which M5S got 32.7% of the votes, while the League got 17.4% of the vote. Together they barely have 50% of the popular vote, but due to Italy’s mix of proportional representation and first past the post system, the joint M5S-League coalition has 352 out of 630 seats in the Chamber of Deputies and 170 out of 321 Senate seats. Meanwhile, the more centrist Democratic Party (the main party in the previous government) and Forza Italia (Silvio Berlusconi’s party) suffered major losses.
The initial coalition proposal was rejected by Italian President Sergio Matarella, due to its inclusion of a strongly anti-Euro finance minister. This led to concerns in financial markets about a new election as early as July 2018, in which M5S and the League were likely to win an even stronger majority. However, in the end MS5 and the League came to a coalition agreement without the controversial Eurosceptic finance ministry candidate.
The main cause of the political dissatisfaction leading up to the new coalition is a prolonged economic stagnation, which started well before the 2008 Global Financial Crisis (GFC). Italian real GDP per capita is now below its level 20 years ago, before the Eurozone was launched. In comparison, other major European economies have continued becoming richer, though at a slow pace by historical standards.
Italy’s abysmal economic performance in the last 20 years reflects several factors:
- Dysfunctional legal and political institutions: high levels of corruption, inefficient administration and business laws, excessive regulations for e.g. starting a new business.
- Lower penetration of computers and other information and communication technologies (ICT), combined with greater prevalence of corporate management practices that discourage higher adoption of ICT and other productivity improvements.
- Relatively low education levels of the workforce: the quality of secondary education is below the OECD average, a significantly above average proportion of adults have low literacy or numeracy levels, and the proportion of adults with University education is much lower than the OECD average.
- A credit boom in 2001-2007 that directed more funds to sectors with lower productivity but higher access to the financial system, leading to misallocation of capital and other production inputs.
European Commission analysis of structural reforms suggests that if Italy had successfully closed around half of its structural gaps relative to best practice among EU countries, it would have boosted its GDP per capita in the last 20 years by 16%.
Various governments in the past 20 years have failed to solve these problems due to a mixture of unwillingness to confront special interests, corruption, and the sheer complexity of major economic reforms.
The New Coalition’s Economic Programme: Fiscal Stimulus but with Potential for Financial Crisis
The new coalition’s economic programme does not offer any solutions to these deep structural problems. Instead, coalition plans include spending increases and tax cuts worth 6-7% of GDP annually. Key elements of the new government’s economic programme include the following:
- Persons below a certain income will get 780 Euros basic monthly income from the government. The minimum monthly pension will also increase to 780 Euros.
- The current income tax will be replaced by a flatter structure, with 15% and 20% rates, in addition to a 3000 Euros annual deduction for families.
- Planned increases in consumption taxes worth 12.5 billion Euros will be abandoned.
- Plans to gradually raise the retirement age will be dropped.
- Reform of Eurozone institutions, in particular a loosening of the current Stability and Growth pact that limits budget deficits to 3% of GDP.
On the surface, these plans amount to a massive fiscal stimulus. However, given the large amount of Italian government debt (now exceeding 130% of GDP) and Italy’s already high borrowing costs, the positive multiplier effect on GDP growth is likely to be much lower than in typical fiscal stimulus episodes. The impact on GDP would be close to zero in our baseline outlook, after factoring in the negative impact on financial markets and business confidence.
Italian borrowing costs spiked during the coalition formation process, on fears of a new election leading to an even stronger populist majority, and the negative impact of a populist fiscal programme on Italy’s high debt levels. The spread between Italian and German government 10-year bond yields reached 2.9% on May 29th, just before the new coalition was approved, compared to 1.4% in January 2018. It is still at 2.3% in mid-June.
Uncertainty and Downside Risks Have Increased
In our baseline forecast Italy’s economy expands by 1.1-1.7% in 2018 and by 0.8-1.6% in 2019. This assumes debt market turbulence is contained, with positive fiscal stimulus effects compensating for the higher costs of borrowing in Italy. We assign the baseline scenario a 20-25% probability.
On the upside, fiscal stimulus effects could dominate, leading to GDP growth of 1.2-1.8% in 2018 and 1.7-2.5% in 2019. We assign this most likely optimistic scenario a 15-25% probability.
On the downside, further increases in Italian borrowing costs could lead to a slowdown, with GDP growth declining to 1-1.6% in 2018 and 0-0.7% in 2019. We assign this most likely pessimistic scenario a 15-25% probability. A more significant spike in Italian bond yields could lead to a more severe downturn, with GDP contracting by 0.2-1% in 2019. We assign the major downturn scenario a 10-20% probability.
What about Italexit Risks?
The new Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte has reiterated that the new government will not hold a referendum on Eurozone membership. However, the current loose fiscal policy plans of the coalition puts it on a collision course with financial markets that could ultimately force a Eurozone exit. The dynamics of this Italexit scenario have some similarity to earlier Grexit scenarios from the summer 2015, but on a much larger scale.
There are several factors that are likely to prevent a default on Italian debt or Italexit:
- Around two thirds of Italian government debt is domestically held. Any default or significant restructuring will mainly hurt Italian banks and households holding government bonds. The coalition is unlikely to take actions that directly lead to such an own-goal.
- The government’s budget needs approval from both houses of parliament, and the coalition’s majority in the Senate is weaker, potentially disappearing under threat of a crisis.
- The Italian constitution states that the government must ensure a balanced budget over some horizon and guarantee the sustainability of its debt. A budget that imposes an excessively high deficit could be deemed unconstitutional and blocked by Italian President Matarella.
In a crisis situation, these factors may cause a scaling back of the current fiscal plans, a breakdown in the current coalition, or a constitutional crisis that would raise political uncertainty but avoid an Italexit. Nevertheless, the estimated probability of an Italexit over a 1-year horizon has increased from 0-5% in April to 5-15% in June.
Spill-overs from Italy to the rest of the Eurozone are likely to be moderate, even under an Italexit scenario. This reflects a reduced exposure of other European banks to Italian debt after the 2011-2014 Eurozone Crisis, and better tools at the ECB for handling financial market shocks. Nevertheless, some financial contagion risks remain. We have increased the probabilities of a Eurozone recession scenario from 4-9% to 5-10% at a 1-year horizon.
For further enquiries, please contact Daniel Solomon, Economist, at Daniel.Solomon@euromonitor.com.
About the Author
Daniel Solomon joined Euromonitor International in 2011 and is responsible for macro-economic modelling and analysis. His areas of expertise include business cycles, financial markets and the macroeconomy, dynamic general equilibrium models and applied macro econometrics. Daniel holds a Master of Science in Management/Finance from Queen’s University - Queen’s School of Business, Canada, a Master of Arts in Economics from McGill University, Canada and a Ph.D. in Economics from the Université de Montréal, Canada.
Euromonitor International is the world's leading independent provider of strategic market research. With 15 offices around the world and in-country analysts in over 100 countries, Euromonitor International provides statistics, analysis and reports, as well as breaking news on industries, economies and consumers worldwide. We connect market research to your company goals and annual planning by analysing market context, competitor insight and future trends impacting businesses worldwide.
5-year economic forecasts on 30+ economic indicators for 127 countries & 33 commodities.
Date: June 18, 2018
TagsBrazil Major Economies Italy Canada Asia Iran Ukraine Base Metals Commodities IMF Unemployment rate Nordic Economies Greece Precious Metals Commodities Euro Area Tunisia Healthcare MENA Housing Market Gold TPP South Africa Energy Commodities Brexit Economic Growth (GDP) Africa Exchange Rate oil prices Trade UK European Union Latin America Vietnam Company News OPEC Colombia Venezuela Commodities precious metals Inflation France United Kingdom USA Consensus Forecast Oil Spain China Eastern Europe Australia Portugal Cryptocurrency Russia Infographic Turkey United States India G7 Emerging Markets Germany Japan Bitcoin Argentina Agricultural Commodities Banking Sector Investment Sub-Saharan Africa Forex Mexico
7 minutes ago
1 hour ago
2 hours ago
Global commodity prices set to increase 6.9% in Q4 2018 from the same period in 2017, mainly due to higher energy a… https://t.co/dVa75QrBr4
2 hours ago
Start getting prepared for iMONEY EXPO 2018! Registration available at https://t.co/K3CyVVbeOv
2 hours ago
- How can Latin America’s business environment benefit from technological change?
- Mexico: A look at the past, present and future as elections loom
- Italy’s New Populist Government and the Eurozone: Prelude to a Crisis?
- Latin America moves toward increased integration as U.S. protectionism grows
- How can Latin America increase productivity without affecting the quality of employment?
- How will Saudi Arabia's economy benefit from lifting the women's driving ban?
- Which countries are the most prepared for the upcoming digital revolution?
- India Under Pressure from the U.S. on Trade Policy
- The Story of Steel
- Latin America is the World Leader in eCommerce Growth Despite Serious Challenges
- What the TPP means for trade in Latin America
- Elections in Russia: Analysis and Implications
- 2018 & 2019 Economic Outlook for the Top Oil Producing Countries
- Nearly a Third of Latin Americans Have No Right to a Pension
- A Look at Healthcare Models Around the World
- The Poorest Countries in the World
- Newly-elected Chilean President Sebastian Piñera faces a myriad of challenges - economic and otherwise
- The Economic Effects of Trade Protectionism
- Regional Disparity: The Dark Side of Inequality in Latin America
- Coal: The story of the world's most abundant fossil fuel
- Gold: The Most Precious of Metals (Part 3)
- Venezuela's Electoral Conundrum
- Trump's 1st Year: 95 Analysts Surveyed on U.S. Economy
- The Latest on China and What's in Store for 2018
- An in-depth look at the Eurozone’s booming economy and the challenges that lurk in the shadows
- China’s growing influence on the Latin American economy
- Top Economics & Finance Blogs of 2018
- How Latin America emerged from recession in 2017
- Is this the beginning of the end for Bitcoin?
- Risks and Opportunities for 2018 - Daniel Lacalle
- Emerging Markets 2018 Economic Outlook
- The role of FDI in Vietnam’s socio-economic development
- Increasing poverty in Latin America takes a breather thanks to improving economic dynamics
- What will be the most miserable economies in 2018?
- The World's Top 10 Largest Economies
- Is Spain doing enough to address its high youth unemployment rate?
- Has Latin America gone far enough in reducing barriers to international trade?
- Commodities Outlook: Oil, Natural Gas, Coal, Lead & Tin
- 21 experts tell us what the future looks like for cryptocurrencies and blockchain
- Turkish lira plummets to all-time low on Erdogan’s monetary feud and tense U.S.-Turkey relations
- Copper: The first metal mastered by man
- The Mercosur-EU Free Trade Agreement: Obstacles & Opportunities
- Nigerian Economy Still Treading Water Thanks to Oil Sector
- Elections in Chile: What the results could mean for the economy
- QE’s Untold Story: A Chart That Fed Correspondents Need To Investigate
- Holland’s fragile one-seat majority government targets economic growth at the expense of fiscal sustainability
- South Africa: Economy at a tipping point?
- Latin American Commodities: What’s behind the increase in demand and prices?
- Is the UK really "shackled to a corpse"?
- Spain-Catalonia: 7 economic experts weigh in on how the situation will affect the outlook
- How well is Spain's labor market doing since the crisis?
- Which countries will have the highest and lowest inflation in 2017?
- How vulnerable is Latin America to economic crises today?
- Iron ore facts and common questions answered
- The bulging economic costs of obesity
- How much investment is needed to salvage Latin America’s crumbling infrastructure?
- A Look at the Potential Impact of Brexit on the Dutch Economy
- Emerging Markets Are Kicking Into Higher Gear In 2017
- Why is foreign direct investment in Latin America falling again?
- Are Central Banks Nationalising the Economy?
- Bounty or burden? The impact of refugees on European economies is far from clear
- What’s the future of U.S.-Latin America trade relations?
- Taxes or cutbacks? Latin America's challenge of sustaining spending without causing debt to skyrocket
- Are uranium prices making a comeback?
- Taxing the Economy: Achieving a Delicate Balance
- How will Latin America’s upcoming lengthy election cycle affect the reform agenda and credit ratings?
- How will emerging market economies perform in 2017?
- Chilean Economy in Focus: Interview with Senior Economist of the Chamber of Commerce of Santiago
- CEOs Rank Top Economies for Growth Opportunities
- The Mobile Ecosystem & Latin America's Economy
- Prospects and Challenges for the Global Economy: Interview with Tim Cooper from BMI Research
- How will the Fed reduce its balance sheet & and how will the ECB end QE? - 19 economic experts weigh in
- Thoughts on "unwinding" QE from Frances Coppola
- The Fed and ECB at a crossroads: Unwinding QE
- Spain: The economy that continues to silence the critics
- Latin America: The Most Unequal Region in the World
- The History of OPEC: Has it been a Success?
- FocusEconomics Announces 2017 Analyst Forecast Awards Winners
- Latin America’s rising unemployment bucks nearly decade long trend
- Escape from the Central Bank Trap by Daniel Lacalle
- China's economic rebalancing act: What to look out for in 2017
- Driving Growth in Latin America: Challenges & Priorities
- Is the Global Economy Rebalancing?
- Commodity exporters face challenging times
- Recent Global Events Facilitate Mercosur-Pacific Alliance
- 23 economic experts weigh in: Why is productivity growth so low?
- Mexico's outlook as Trump nears 100-day mark
- Interview with Oxford Economics Senior Economist on implications of the possible outcomes of the French Presidential Election
- The anxiety of the small saver in a world of negative interest rates
- Brexit negotiations. Between Uncertainty and Urgency
- An Economic History of the EU from El Blog Salmón
- Baby Boomin': Implications of high population growth in Latin America
- Survey of International Economists Predicts a Le Pen Defeat in French Elections, Says Macron has Best Economic Plan
- Spain in a global context: developed economy with some challenges
- How much is crime costing Latin America?
- Predictions & Estimates from Economist Daniel Lacalle
- What economy will the new Dutch government inherit?
- “The data is not a true reflection of reality in India” Interview with Société Générale India Economist
- What are the prospects for Emerging Economies in 2017?
- What to expect in Asia for 2017
- Top Economics & Finance Blogs of 2017
- Latam to Resume Moderate Growth in 2017 but Important Risks Plague Outlook
- 4 Key European Elections That Will Impact the Economy in 2017
- How are security concerns and political chaos affecting Turkey’s economy?
- Global growth to edge up in 2017
- Set to breach targets again? Debt and deficit outlooks for Southern European Eurozone countries in 2016 & 2017
- What does Donald Trump mean for the U.S. economy?
- How will emerging markets perform in 2017?
- The economic impact of a break in U.S.-Philippines ties
- Trump election: Base metals surge due to infrastructure plan
- 5 updates on the Venezuelan economic crisis
- Canada: When your neighbor’s house is on fire…
- Short-term pain before long-term gain? A look at French labor reform and economic growth
- Asia: Unremarkable growth & unfulfilled promises?
- How India's latest monsoon is affecting the economy
- Russian economy update in wake of OPEC deal announcement
- Innovation in Latin America: Potential Goes Untapped Due to Weak Economic Conditions
- The Wisdom of the Crowds and the Consensus Forecast
- Can the peso predict the U.S. election results?
- There's no end in sight to the Venezuela crisis
- A Look at the European Union Political Calendar
- Survey of international economists shows uncertainty surrounding elections damaging U.S. growth prospects
- FocusEconomics partners with leading online statistics provider Statista
- China: Recent postive economic data may be papering over the cracks
- Sub-Saharan Africa's 2016 & 2017 growth rates
- The Italian Dilemma: Weak banks pose risk to already faltering domestic demand
- How much money do migrants from Latin America send home?
- The U.S.' (Not So) Mysterious Case of the Missing Men
- What to expect from the G20 economies by 2020
- The Pain in Spain: Robust GDP growth cannot mask the persistent structural deficit