Which ASEAN countries are most exposed in the event of a U.S.-China trade war?

The pounding of the trade war drums is growing ever more deafening, with the U.S. and China currently engaged in an escalating, tit-for-tat tariff battle. The latest salvo came on 23 August when a fresh raft of tariffs came into force and two days of trade talks in Washington drew a blank. Many are still hopeful that common sense will prevail, but what if negotiations fall through? What would happen if analysts’ worst fears are realized, and we enter a full-blown trade war? What would be the impact on the export-oriented economies of the ASEAN region?

China & U.S. as % of total exports 2016

Reciprocal blanket tariffs would almost certainly shave several decimals off growth in both countries and dampen global economic activity. This spells bad news for the more export-dependent ASEAN economies, such as Singapore, Vietnam, Malaysia and Thailand. Of these four economies, Vietnam and Malaysia export the most to the U.S. and China as a percent of total exports, potentially making them more exposed. In addition, Singapore, Malaysia and Thailand have sizeable manufacturing sectors, highly integrated into global value chains which would be severely disrupted by tariffs.

However, this doesn’t tell us the whole story. Although Indonesia and the Philippines—by nature of their huge domestic markets—are less export-oriented, they are more exposed to the likely financial market fallout from a full-fledged trade war. Due to their weak current account positions, both countries could experience capital outflows and sharp currency depreciations. This tendency has already been observed so far in 2018, with the rupiah and the peso losing substantial ground against the dollar on rising economic uncertainty. This could necessitate even higher interest rates in these countries, dampening economic growth.

Exports of goods and services as % of GDP 2017 ASEAN countries

However, it isn’t all doom and gloom. The impact on ASEAN’s smaller countries should be mild, given that they are less plugged into the global economy. In particular, Brunei—which has extremely low exposure to the U.S. and China and relies heavily on Japan—appears well shielded. 

The U.S.-China tariffs could even offer certain upsides to ASEAN. In particular, some companies based in China could move more manufacturing operations to ASEAN countries to circumvent tariffs. Possible beneficiaries include Malaysia’s chemical industry and Vietnam’s consumer goods sector. Plus, Chinese tariffs on U.S. primary products could help Thai fruit exporters and Myanmar cattle owners grab a larger slice of the Asian giant’s market.

But despite these silver linings, the impact of a trade war on ASEAN will still be resoundingly negative. In a now-infamous tweet, President Donald Trump once remarked that “trade wars are good, and easy to win”. Few ASEAN countries are likely to share his enthusiasm.


Sample Report

5-year economic forecasts on 30+ economic indicators for 127 countries & 33 commodities.

Download

Author: Oliver Reynolds, Economist

Date: August 29, 2018

Tags: 

Twitter @FocusEconomics

  • Panama's economy is set to regain momentum this year on the back of the ramp-up in production at the Cobre Panama m… https://t.co/1VSuAjWx9r

    1 hour ago

  • Measures underway to improve Colombia's fiscal account will likely restrain the pace of expansion in 2019. Read mor… https://t.co/iCfPnVCrmE

    17 hours ago

  • Venezuela's economy is seen contracting 10.3% in 2019, which is down 1.9 percentage points from last month's foreca… https://t.co/lkB8zhWaHY

    19 hours ago

  • Precious metal prices are seen rising 6.1% in Q4 2019 compared to the same period of 2018 (previous month: +4.8% ye… https://t.co/42pkJS5aeo

    22 hours ago

  • Dominican GDP is seen growing 5.1% in 2019, which is up 0.1 percentage points from last month's forecast. Find out… https://t.co/AQay04xqi3

    1 day ago

Blog archive

Search form