Survey of international economists shows uncertainty surrounding elections damaging U.S. growth prospects
A new survey by FocusEconomics shows that the majority of the 72 international macroeconomic experts polled believe the U.S. economy is suffering due to political uncertainty. Looking forward, economists from leading institutions around the world think that the U.S. economy will grow faster under Hillary Clinton’s plan in both the short- and medium-term. Overall, the broad Consensus among economists is that Clinton would manage the economy much better than Donald Trump.
Click on the image to open a full-sized version
Most economists surveyed believe election-related uncertainty is hampering U.S. economic activity. While any election spurs some uncertainty, 60% of respondents to the FocusEconomics survey suggest the current economic cycle is particularly unusual in its behavior.
“Analysts see the current uncertainty over tax reforms, healthcare and general political environment holding back investment and denting 2016 growth prospects,” said Ricardo Aceves, Senior Economist for the United States at FocusEconomics. Analysts have trimmed their GDP growth forecasts for the U.S. over the course of this year and now expect growth of 1.6% in 2016, which is down from 2.5% at the beginning of the year.
Looking at each candidate’s individual policy areas, the economic experts surveyed rated Clinton higher than Trump in all areas. Clinton received the highest score for her immigration policy, followed by monetary and energy policies. The Democratic candidate received lower marks in tax reform and government spending. On the other hand, Trump obtained the highest marks for his minimum wage and energy policies, while he scored low for immigration and foreign trade.
“In order to keep the economy moving, analysts rate Clinton’s overall economic plan higher than Trump’s, credit her with a better grasp of economics, and think her more likely to appoint a good economic team,” noted Aceves.
On appointing the best economic team, economists clearly prefer Clinton: by 75% to roughly 6%, they think the Democratic candidate will be surrounded by the best team of economic policy advisors and that she will make wiser appointments to the Federal Reserve.
U.S. Elections Special Report
Poll of 70+ macroeconomists
Latest U.S. forecasts from the world's leading institutionsDownload Report
The majority of the surveyed economic experts think that under Clinton’s plan the U.S. economy will grow faster in both the short- and medium-term, with interest rates increasing moderately. “Stimulus will go through education, infrastructure spending, immigration and minimum wages,” said Gregory Daco, Chief U.S. Economist at Oxford Economics.
Meanwhile, Trump’s fiscal policies are expected to be highly stimulatory initially, but his other policies are likely to be inflationary and given that the economy is near full employment, the Fed’s reaction will likely be stronger. Analysts also consider Trump’s trade policies as highly disruptive both domestically and abroad. Under Trump's proposed economic plan, “in the short run vast fiscal stimulus, including tax cuts, would strengthen growth. But in the long run, a combination of protectionism and a yawning fiscal gap would hurt confidence in the economy,” commented Tim Cooper, Global Economist at BMI Research.
The FocusEconomics U.S. Elections Survey, released Tuesday, was conducted 12 to 19 September among chief economists and senior economists from leading international and local economic institutions worldwide.
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of FocusEconomics S.L.U. Views, forecasts or estimates are as of the date of the publication and are subject to change without notice. This report may provide addresses of, or contain hyperlinks to, other internet websites. FocusEconomics S.L.U. takes no responsibility for the contents of third party internet websites.
Date: September 28, 2016
TagsInvestmentColombiaUkraineHousing MarketUKDraghiEurozonepublic debtEconomic CrisisInfographicCanadaGDPRussiaPrecious Metals CommoditiesAseanBase MetalsAustraliaJapanUnemployment rateIsraelprecious metalsUnited StatesGermanyArgentinaSpainForexPortugalVietnamCommoditiesBrazilGreeceBrexitEastern EuropeTPSLatin AmericaLagardeinterviewSouth AfricaExchange RateCannabisEconomic DebtBase Metals CommoditiesIranEuropean UnionAsiaUnited KingdomCryptocurrencyVenezuelaItalyCanadian EconomyTunisiaEconomic Growth (GDP)AfricaIndiaG7Euro AreaBitcoinTPPelectionSub-Saharan AfricaHealthcareBanking SectorNordic EconomiesMENACentral AmericaMexicoEnergy CommoditiesAgricultural CommoditiesCopperChinaIMFTradeInflationGoldAsian Financial CrisisFranceEmerging MarketsUSAOPECConsensus Forecasteconomic growthMajor Economiesoil pricesOilCompany NewsTurkey
Peru: Business sentiment improves in November but remains in pessimistic territoryhttps://t.co/rx4D4m4upk
14 minutes ago
Indonesia: Retail sales gain momentum in Octoberhttps://t.co/bjOhqotbaq
26 minutes ago
Romania: Growth slumps to over five-year low in Q3 https://t.co/GBwenwCC7J
55 minutes ago
China: Inflation hits near eight-year high in November, stoked by African swine fever https://t.co/ZAkDNFzLGr
3 hours ago
According to Carsten Brzeski, chief economist at ING Germany, the data "suggests that the German economy is continu… https://t.co/rheUaIIzLX
3 hours ago